Skip to main content

AN ALERT TIME: STOP! WATER THEFT

 Water is a critical ingredient of modern civilization. Without clean water, life cannot be sustained. Around the world water supply, nearly 30% to 50% is stolen per each year, mainly by agricultural interests and farmers, yet the crime itself is not well understood, a new international case study led by the University of Adelaide reported a research article on the “Grand theft water and the calculus of compliance” in the Nature Sustainability journal on 24th August 2020 [1]. They mentioned that “water crises constitute a challenge for humanity. Uncertain supply and growing demand are driving higher water theft, particularly by agricultural users who account for approximately 70% of global use. However, research into water theft is under explored in all disciplines”.

 

Figure 1. Water theft and stop it.

This research paper provides a conceptual framework and modeling approach that can be designed to improve the understanding of both individual and institutional barriers to water theft. The framework and model will explore how effective detection, prosecution, conviction and penalties can be assessed. Three case studies have tested the validity of their framework. 

 

Cause for water demand

The global climate changes are increasing demands and competition of water and putting more pressure on water supplies. This increased the demand for water which may result in higher costs, which could, in turn, increase the price of raw materials and crops needed to manufacture consumer goods like beverages. New regulations have putting caps on industrial water withdrawals and are also anticipated, further increasing the competition for water supplies.

Water sustainability programs can help companies address supply and demand issues by using the water more efficiently, reducing the amount of water needed to manufacture their products.

Dr. A. Loch from the university’s Centre for Global Food and Resources, says based on the case study “Individuals and companies may be responsible for the act of theft, the phenomenon reflects a systematic failure of arrangements (political, legal, institutional, and so on). In addition, when regulators fail to understand the value of water, in adequate prescribed penalties will increase the risk of theft. We have also invited others to test our framework, to apply our model and engage in a wider conversation about water theft”.

 

Theoretical drivers of illegal activities in Nature Sustainability [1]:

  • ­­­­Deviation from social norms due to differences between rule breakers and compliant users.
  • Deviation from social norms due to differences in personal moral development.
  • Conditioning of behavior by the environmental context.
  • Individual views on legitimacy and fairness of rules, and the penalties involved.
  • Benefits and costs of illegal activities.

 

Some important cases were noted in their article such as Australian water resources where theft may be compounded by perceptions of general non-compliance [2] although inverse results have been reported in European countries [3]. On contrast, in a South Indian case [4], theft was more commonly perpetrated by downstream users desperate for supply, where different management systems to control illegal extraction were employed at top and tail areas with positive results. Theft was also minimized in Andean irrigation systems via shared social objectives, widespread assumption of high compliance rates and effective monitoring [5]. Furthermore, where groundwater resources can substitute surface water, understanding their shared connectivity may minimize tipping points from changes in use [6]. In such settings, cultural values may play a major role in changing social norms towards compliance and the deterrence of breaking rules [7,8], especially where individual accountability is ignored and regulatory controls do not mitigate resource exploitation [9]. Finally, if the probability of successful prosecution is low and the penalty is comparatively small, stronger deterrents maybe needed to dissuade users from stealing water to maximize profits [10] and/or lowering total resource sustainability.

 

Figure 2. Water is a precious matter in the world and to save water.

A. Loch et al., summarized a final consequence of increased surface-water monitoring and compliance could be an increase and may also diminish incentives to steal. The surface-water use is affected by pumping or increased restriction to legal/illegal use; groundwater becomes a more valuable product since it may not be perceived as being, subject to similar restrictions [11]. This would have place groundwater resources and any associated rights or markets under stress (if not already), particularly where as resourcing associated with bore monitoring and the compliance checks were reduced. In the preceding cases, where we remain uncertain about whether current levels of environmental rights can provide national benefits, we can be certain that any infringement on those rights via lawful/unlawful extraction will make the systems unsustainable. Once again, this highlights the importance of closing existing legal options to extract environmental flows and implementing effective compliance monitoring and assessment across the full spectrum of water resources as the first steps toward an effective deterrent to water theft.

 

References

  1. A. Loch et al., Nature Sustainability (2020), https://doi.org/10.1038/s41893-020-0589-3.
  2. C. Holley, D. Sinclair, Australas. J. Nat. Resour. Law Policy 17, 189 (2014).
  3. European Report on Water Crimes (RECEE, 2017).
  4. R. Wade, Agric. Adm. 17, 177 (1984).
  5. P.B. Trawick, Hum. Ecol. 29, 1 (2001).
  6. J.C. Castilla-Rho et al., Nat. Hum. Behav.1, 640 (2017).
  7. J. Castilla-Rho et al., Glob. Environ. Change 58, 101972 (2019).
  8. R. Wade, World Bank Res. Obs. 2, 219 (1987).
  9. L. De Stefano, E. Lopez-Gunn, Water Policy 14, 147 (2012).
  10. R. Greiner et al., Australia. Land Use Policy 51, 26 (2016).
  11. I. Ray, J. Williams, J. Dev. Econ. 67, 129 (2002).

Blog Written By

Dr. A. S. GANESHRAJA

Assistant Professor

National College, Tiruchirappalli

Tamil Nadu, India

Editors

Dr. S. Chandrasekar

Dr. K. Rajkumar

Reviewers

Dr. Y. Sasikumar

Dr. S. Thirumurugan

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Designing of Corrosion Resistant Alloys via Percolation Theory

Canada and USA Scientists have reported on designing of corrosion-resistant alloys via percolation theory and published in Nature Materials on 01 February 2021. Nickel–chromium, Iron–chromium binary alloys can serve as the prototypical corrosion-resistant metals owing to its presence of a nanometre-thick protective passive oxide film. The main key criterion for good passive behavior is the passive film should be compromised via a scratch or abrasive wear that can be reformed with a little metal dissolution. This could be a principal reason for the stainless steels and other chromium containing alloys that are used for critical applications which ranges from nuclear reactor components to biomedical implants. A long-standing unanswered question in corrosion science is the unravelling of the compositional dependence of the electrochemical behavior of the alloys [ 1, 2 ]. The discovery of the family of these alloys were increased its rate with the advent of artificial intelligence, da...

Innovations of Integrated Artificial Intelligence

Artificial intelligence (AI) is the study of methods to imitate intelligent human behavior. AI is widely heralded as an ongoing “revolution” transforming science and society altogether [ 1 , 2 ]. While approaches to AI such as machine learning, deep learning and artificial neural networks are reshaping data processing and analysis [ 3 ], healthcare, transportation and the production chain [ 4 ].  Figure 1. Integrated concept of artificial intelligence. AI Ethics Guidelines National and international organizations (European Commission, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), UK House of Lords, Singapore Commission) have responded to these concerns by developing ad hoc expert committees on AI, often mandated to draft policy documents in various countries. In 2018 alone, companies such as Google and SAP publicly released AI guidelines and principles. The advisory council on the ethical use of AI scientific team have announced that results reveal a global co...

Electro-Organic Synthesis: Next Emerging Technique

Industrial developments, excessive energy consumption, sustainable technologies, environmental cleaning processes are major topics of political and social discourse. Current innovations are rated not only focusing on their benefit and utility but also concerning their eco-friendly approaches. The development of green technological processes is becoming more important and requires harmless energy sources. Particularly over the past decade, the severe limitations of fossil resources intensify the movement towards sustainable synthesis techniques with a strict cutback in the ecological footprint [ 1 ]. Electro-organic synthesis belongs to the synthetic organic chemistry discipline that facilities the direct use of electricity to generate valuable compounds. Hence, it is possible to transfer green aspects of sustainable energy sources to the whole production process [ 2 ]. Since the Kolbe’s discoveries of using electricity as a reagent for organic transformations over 170 years ago, ...

PROSPECTS ON PHOTOBIOREFINERY

Very recently, Prof. Dr. K. Faungnawakij and his research group have summarized a mini review report on an emerging renewable technique of Photobiorefinery . This is one of the beyond technique of Artificial Photosynthesis (AP) [1] . Despite great promises, AP technologies for solar H2 production and CO2 reduction are far uncompetitive to other promising technologies at the current stage . However, despite an enormous effort, time, and budget paid on AP-related researches throughout several decades, AP technologies have struggled to strive beyond laboratory demonstration except a very few exceptions [2] . This bitter reality makes the translation of this excellent science to practical application questionable [3] . Technoeconomic analysis shows that without achieving the aggressive technology targets, this technology will not be commercially viable. This has directed the research community towards the development of highly efficient yet expensive devices. While tremendous p...

Bifunctional Water Splitting Catalysts: Large Current Density

Fuel cell technology is one of the most emerging fields with ecofriendly and everlasting energy source way of producing energy for the urgent requirements. Further it needs to be improved to make it cheap and more environmental friendly. Among all fuel cells, the hydrogen (H 2 ) and oxygen (O 2 ) fuel cell is the one with zero carbon emission, more ecofriendly, high potential and the byproduct is just only the water. However, supplying the fuels in the purest form (at least the H 2 ) is very essential to ensure higher life cycles and less decay in cell efficiency. Nowadays, commercially available large scale H 2 production is mainly dependent on steam reforming of fossil fuels which can also generates CO 2 along with H 2 and the source that is going to be depleted, and this byproduct is not environmental friendly. Therefore, an emerging alternate technology is needed; in this case the electrolysis of water has given a greater attention than the steam reforming.  Recently man...

Sustainable Bio-energy Fuels

  The trend of exploring new sources of fuel for automobiles is increasing over the past decade, where the use of biodiesel as alternatives for fossil fuels is investigated exclusively, due to its potential of decreasing greenhouse gas and air pollutant emissions. Production and use of biodiesel can encourage the agricultural industry and provide self-reliance on automobile fuels which in turn boosts regional economic development. Biofuels or biodiesel is widely used as hybrid fuel in more than 20 countries around the world with an account annual consumption of over 2 million tons  [ 1 ] .  Figure 1. Credit to SNB. As an example in this context, considering the Hong Kong region, the increasing interest among the public to reduce air pollution drives them to use biodiesel as fuels. The environmental protection department of Hong Kong has conducted a feasibility study at the University of Hong Kong on the use of biodiesel as an automotive fuel in Hong Kong. The main motivat...

Application of the MOFs-Drug Delivery System

Metal Organic Frameworks (MOFs) are constructed by metal ions/clusters and multidentate organic linkers via coordination bonds (reticular synthesis) have significantly enriched the domain of porous materials [ 1 , 2 ]. Based on the flexibility of the constituents, geometry, size and functionality, MOFs with a crystalline nature possess extremely high surface areas (typically ranging from 1000 to 10,000 m 2 g -1 ) and tunable pore sizes/characteristics. These aspects endow MOFs with fantastic functionalities/properties for a variety of applications such as gas adsorption, separation, catalysis, sensors, drug delivery, proton conduction etc [ 2 ]. In the de novo synthesis of MOFs, ligands with relatively high pKa (e.g. azoles) easily produce robust frameworks with low-valent metal ions, while linkers with relatively low pKa (e.g. carboxylic acids) tend to bind with high-valent metal ions to give stable structures. In general, dense and rigid frameworks are constructed by rigid and h...

Novel Approach of Plastic Waste to Flash Graphene

Prof. Algozeeb and his research collaboration team have investigated an novel approach of upcycling plastic waste (PW) products to flash graphene (FG). This method relies on Flash Joule Heating (FJH) to convert PW into FG. A sequential direct current (DC) and alternating current (AC) flash is used in order to make a high-quality graphene. In this FJH process, they established without catalyst and works for PW mixtures that can make the process suitable for handling landfill PW.  In 21 st century, PW pollution is considerable one among the various environmental issues. A very large fraction of PW ends up in the ocean, which leads to the formation of micro- and nanoplastics that threaten marine life, micro-organisms, useful bacteria, and humans. From the intense carbon footprint process, most of these synthesized plastics are used only once before dumping into landfills or water ways that terminate in the oceans. Hence, upcycling PW to higher value materials and chemicals is econ...

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN SPINTRONIC DEVICES

Spintronics is one of the emerging fields for the next-generation nanoelectronic devices that are used to reduce their power consumption, and increase their memory and processing capabilities. Such devices used for the spin degree of freedom of electrons and/or holes, which can also interact with their orbital moments [ 1 ]. However, for spintronic devices to meet the ever-increasing demands of the industry, innovation in terms of materials, processes, and circuits are required.  Figure 1. Schematic diagram for major methods to generate a spin-polarised current [ 2 ]. Spin-polarised electrons can be generated in non-magnetic (NM) materials using the following methods [ 2 ]: spin injection from a ferromagnetic (FM), a magnetic field, an electric field, an electromagnetic wave introduction, a thermal gradient, Zeeman splitting, spin motive force, and mechanical rotation (see Figure 1 ). One of the most common methods is spin injection from a FM material, e.g., conventional FM meta...

Unexpected Attention of Non-nuclear Blasts in 2020

Ammonium nitrate salt (NH 4 NO 3 ) is a white crystal solid, highly soluble in water. It is predominantly used as a high-nitrogen fertilizer in agriculture and also a component of explosive mixtures in mining, quarrying, and civil construction. Generally, the ammonium nitrate is produced by neutralizing nitric acid (HNO 3 ) with ammonia (NH 3 ) ( Fig ure 1 ). The process involves the various unit process operations including (a) solution formation and concentration, (b) solid formation, (c) finishing, (d) screening and coating, and (e) product bagging or bulk shipping [1] . Figure 1. Synthesis of ammonium nitrate salt and structure. In the early 20 th century, disasters are turned to regular happening in the manufacturing of ammonium nitrate, but more recent. Lebanon’s main capital Beirut was rocked on 4 th August by an explosion that has killed at least 220 people and injured 6000 and 3,00,000 people homeless by using or misusing 2,750 tonnes of ammonium nitrate (Equivalent t...